I bought this book last week and very much enjoyed it. It is a biography of Carl Jung, written by Claire Dunne. It neatly captures his path and it takes the reader through Jung’s life journey, along with his ups and downs.
Similar to some of C.J.’s works, this book is filled with artistic images. These visuals are beneficial for readers, as they help create associations with the text. At times, they even add a magical quality, transitioning the reader between “consuming art” and “consuming text,” which can inspire deeper thought.
As usual, I’ll provide a brief overview here.
Part 1: Wounded
Jung, a psychoanalyst, believed in the importance of the unconscious and spent a lot of time analyzing dreams. Many of his ideas stemmed from this analysis. Jung began studying spirituality during his university years, often finding himself at odds with the official scientific community that dismissed occult phenomena. Jung proposed that in addition to the personal unconscious, which consists of an individual’s repressed and forgotten experiences, there is a collective unconscious. This is a part of the unconscious mind shared by all humans, containing universal memories and archetypes inherited from our ancestors.
In science I missed the factor of meaning – Carl Jung
The strongest element in Jung’s nature was a “a passionate urge toward understanding”.
From the clinical point of view which then prevailed, the human personality of the patient, his individuality, did not matter at all…. Patients were labeled, rubber-stamped with a diagnosis and, for the most part, that settled the matter. The psychology of the mental patient played no role whatsoever. […] I realized that paranoid ideas and hallucinations contain a germ of meaning. A personality, a life history, a pattern of hopes and desires lie behind the psychosis. The fault is ours if we do not understand them. – Carl Jung
I treat every patient as individually as possible, because the solution of the problem is always an individual one. Universal rules can be postulated only with a grain of salt. […] In therapy the problem is always the whole person, never the symptom alone. We must ask questions which challenge the whole personality. – Carl Jung
His first encounter with Freud is when Jung sends him the first letter in which he disagreed that “all of human behaviour” is due to repressed sexuality. Their communication method was mostly letters where they shared intellectual stimulus, excitement of discovery, mutual enjoyment.
I am the clash of the opposites – Carl Jung
The differing views between Jung and Freud on the connection between the mind and the physical world can be illustrated in the scenario: Jung describes an intense feeling in his body that coincides with a loud noise from a nearby bookcase, which startles both him and Freud. Jung interprets the noise as an example of how internal psychological states can manifest in the external world, a phenomenon he calls “catalytic exteriorization“. Freud dismisses this idea as nonsense, but Jung predicts (although is not sure what gave him the certainty) another noise, which then happens, seemingly proving his point.
Freud saw himself as a father figure to Jung. According to the Oedipus myth, the son must slay his father. To Freud, this described sexual jealousy; to Jung, the myth was a metaphor for the new growing from the old.
In another instance, Jung and Freud analyzed each other’s dreams. Jung’s interpretation was limited, so he asked Freud for additional details from his private life. Freud reacted strongly, stating, “I cannot risk my authority!”. This incident strained their relationship, though Jung’s wife Emma helped mend it. This example illustrates how symbolic dreams led Jung deeper into the psyche, resulting in his successful lecture “Transformations and Symbols of the Libido”.
Dear Professor Freud,
May I say a few words to you in earnest? […] your technique of “treating your pupils like patients is a blunder”You go around sniffing out all the symptomatic actions in your vicinity, thus reducing everyone to the level of sons and daughters who blushingly admit the existence of their faults.
Meanwhile you remain on top as the father, sitting pretty….
[…] You know, of course, how far a patient gets with self-analysis: not out of his neurosis – just like you.
After this second (and final) break with Freud, all of Jung’s friends and acquaintances dropped away, his work was declared rubbish and he was declared to be a mystic. This led to Jung’s period of “inner uncertainty” or disorientation.
I lived as if under constant inner pressure. At times this became so strong that I suspected there was some psychic disturbance in myself…. Retrospection led to nothing but a fresh acknowledgment of my own ignorance…. I said to myself, “Since I know nothing at all, I shall simply do whatever occurs to me” […] it was a painfully humiliating experience to realize there was nothing to be done except play childish games. – Carl Jung
My family and my profession always remained a joyful reality and a guarantee that I also had a normal existence. – Carl Jung
The years when I was pursuing my inner images were the most important in my life – in them everything essential was decided […] The knowledge I was concerned with, or was seeking, still could not be found in the science of those days. I myself had to undergo the original experience, and, moreover, try to plant the results of my experience in the soil of reality. It was then that I dedicated myself to service of the psyche. I loved and hated it, but it was my greatest wealth. My delivering of myself over to it […] was the only way by which I could endure my existence and live it as fully as possible. – Carl Jung
Part 2: Healer
Jung believed that Western civilization, with its emphasis on rationality and scientific materialism, had lost touch with the deeper, more intuitive aspects of the human experience.
Jung fought off all attempts to label him a “mystic.” Repeatedly he defined himself as “an empiricist who moved within the limits of a natural empirical science. Central to his Analytical Psychology is the individuation process. It might also be called “coming to selfhood” or “self-realization”.
Our conscious mind is only part of who we are. There is also an unconscious mind that works in the background, influencing us even if we don’t notice it. By becoming aware of this unconscious part, we can understand ourselves and life better. The individuation process is about how the unconscious can help and guide us, often communicating through symbols in our dreams. To understand these messages, we need to pay attention to the signs and symbols our unconscious mind naturally provides.
Dreams reflect many layers of our psyche. At surface level they can show personal contents that have been absorbed subliminally or pushed from the conscious to the upper end of the unconscious. They can also tell us more about ourselves, about other people or events. They can project forward as well as backward in time. From deeper in, new contents can arise revealing creative ideas or germs of future emotional conditions in our psyche. But the unconscious may not take over exclusively. It is under all conditions a most advisable thing to keep to the conscious and rational side, i.e., to maintain that side. One never should lose sight of it. It is the safeguard without which you would lose yourself on unknown seas. – Carl Jung
The initial question to be directed … would be: “Who or what has come alive? … Who or what has entered my psychic life and created disturbances and wants to be heard?” To this you should add: “Let it speak!” Then switch off your noisy consciousness and listen quietly inward and look at the images that appear before your inner eye, or hearken to the words which the muscles of your speech apparatus are trying to form. Write down what then comes without criticism. – Carl Jung
He embarked on expeditions to Africa, driven by a desire to explore the depths of the human psyche beyond the confines of Western civilization. He saw in African cultures a more direct connection to these primordial elements, which he thought could provide valuable insights into the human condition.
In his “Psychological Types”, Jung introduced the four categories of thinking, feeling, sensation, and intuition. His wider aim was to understand the universality of archetypes (inherited mental images or symbols) and the collective unconscious by studying the indigenous cultures, their rituals, and their myths.
I have done without electricity, and tend the fireplace and stove myself. Evenings, I light the old lamps. There is no running water, and I pump the water from the well. I chop the wood and cook the food. These simple acts make man simple; and how difficult it is to be simple! In Bollingen, silence surrounds me almost audibly, and I live “in modest harmony with nature”. – Carl Jung
Some of the key archetypes include:
- The Self: This archetype represents the unified unconsciousness and consciousness of an individual. It is the central governing force of the psyche, striving for balance and wholeness.
- The Persona: This is the mask or public face we present to the world, shaped by social conventions and expectations. It represents the roles we play in society.
- The Shadow: The Shadow embodies the unconscious and often darker aspects of the personality, including repressed weaknesses, desires, and instincts. It is the opposite of the Persona and includes qualities that the conscious mind denies but which are still present.
- The Anima/Animus: These archetypes represent the feminine side of a man (Anima) and the masculine side of a woman (Animus). They embody the true self rather than the image we present to others and are essential for achieving psychological wholeness.
- The Hero: This archetype symbolizes the part of the personality that wants to prove its worth and courage through trials and challenges, often associated with the journey towards self-realization and individuation.
- The Wise Old Man/Woman: Representing wisdom and knowledge, these figures provide guidance and insight. They often appear in dreams or myths as mentors or guides.
- The Trickster: The Trickster is a complex figure that represents chaos, the unexpected, and the breaking of norms and taboos. This archetype challenges the status quo and can be a catalyst for change and transformation.
Part 3: Of the soul
Jung’s development of the internal spiritual self was at the heart of his work:
You are quite right, the main interest of my work is not concerned with the treatment of neurosis but rather with the approach to the numinous. But the fact is that the approach to the numinous is the real therapy – Carl Jung
He was endlessly curious and had a strong desire to engage in meaningful and constructive dialogues with people from various backgrounds.
He dealt graciously and helpfully with my impossible enquiry as to what I should do with my life, knowing nothing about me, and yet no doubt knowing much just by observing. Instead of answering my questions he gave me other, better questions to ask myself over the succeeding months. – Dr. George Hogle, of Carl Jung
Jung sees the duality of the God-image reflected also in humanity: “A paradoxical God image forces man to come to terms with his own paradoxicality.” This corresponding conflict of opposites in acute form brings the human being much suffering and trials which, if endured, can be transcended.
The concept of synchronicity: meaningful coincidences that occur in our lives, events that are not causally related but seem to be connected through their meaning. Jung believed that synchronicity points to an underlying order in the universe, where events are connected through meaning rather than through cause and effect. He saw this as an indication of the deeper connection between the psyche and the external world. For example:
- Personal Experiences: You might be pondering a difficult decision and come across a book that offers exactly the insight you need.
- Psychotherapy: In therapy, a patient might dream about a symbol, and the next day, see the same symbol in real life, which provides insight into their unconscious mind.
Modern physics shattered the absolute validity of natural law and made it relative … But if cause and effect turns out to be only statistically valid and relatively true we have to look for other factors of explanation in explaining natural processes. – Carl Jung
Jung accepted that his work and ideas might not be fully understood or appreciated, and he was also aware of how out of place he sometimes felt in his own era – out of sync with the contemporary world around him.
I have resigned myself to being posthumous, […] sometimes I feel like an anachronism even to myself. – Carl Jung
As the old Chinese saying goes: “The right man sitting in his house and thinking the right thought will be heard a hundred miles away.” – Carl Jung
In alchemy, the “Mysterium Coniunctionis” represents the final goal of the alchemical work: the union of the male and female principles, symbolized by the sun and the moon, the king and the queen. Carl Jung adopted and expanded this concept in his analytical psychology to describe the process of individuation (the psychological journey toward becoming a whole person).
Not unnaturally, we are at a loss to see how a psychic experience of this kind – for such it evidently was – can be formulated as a rational concept. […] We could compare this only with the ineffable mystery of the unio mystica, or tao, or the content of samadhi, or the experience of satori in Zen, which would bring us to the realm of the ineffable and of extreme subjectivity where all the criteria of reason fail. […] It is and remains a secret of the world of psychic experience and can be understood only as a numinous event. – Carl Jung
“Memories, Dreams, Reflections” is Jung’s autobiographical work. MDR offers an in-depth look into Jung’s personal life (childhood, school and student years), relationships (Freud), thoughts, travels, and development of his psychological theories.
As at the beginning of the Christian era, so again today we are faced with the problem of the general moral backwardness which has failed to keep pace with our scientific, technical and social progress… Happiness and contentment, equability of mind and meaningfulness of life – these can be experienced only by the individual and not by a State. […] Man has already received so much knowledge that he can destroy his own planet. Let us hope that God’s good spirit will guide him in his decisions, because it will depend on man’s decision whether God’s creation will continue. – Carl Jung
Flying across the meta skies:
The difference between most people and myself is that for me the “dividing walls” are transparent. That is my peculiarity. Others find these walls so opaque that they see nothing behind them and therefore think nothing is there. To some extent I perceive the processes going on in the background, and that gives me an inner certainty. People who see nothing have no certainties and can draw no conclusions – or do not trust them even if they do. – Carl Jung
The first man is of the earth and is earthly, the second man is of heaven and is heavenly. – Carl Jung
bor0's blog 